Cherreads

The Love I Never Expected

LovestruckTale
7
chs / week
The average realized release rate over the past 30 days is 7 chs / week.
--
NOT RATINGS
4.2k
Views
Synopsis
She loved him for years. He never noticed—until it was too late. Anaya had only one secret: her love for Aarav, her childhood best friend. But when her diary is discovered by classmates, her feelings are exposed to the entire school. Aarav ignores her. The teasing, the stares, the heartbreak—she endures it all, still holding on to the hope that he might love her back someday. Until one night… something breaks inside her, and she walks away. In college, Anaya is ready to move on. That’s when Aarav comes back—this time through a dare. A cruel game that makes her believe he might finally feel the same... until the truth shatters her again. But fate has other plans. Enter Ishaan—the campus basketball captain with a cocky smile and a heart that sees Anaya for who she truly is. He falls for her fire, her strength, her scars. As love blossoms again, Aarav realizes his mistake—but is it already too late? Two boys. One girl. A past full of pain and a future waiting to be claimed. Will Anaya choose the boy who broke her or the one who helped her heal?
VIEW MORE

Chapter 1 - Whispers of a Hidden Heart

Anaya and Aarav had known each other since they were toddlers. Their parents had been best friends long before they were born, so naturally, the two of them grew up together. Their bond was effortless—late-night family dinners, summer vacations at the same hill station, and birthday parties where they always cut the cake together.

They weren't just childhood friends; they were practically family.

But somewhere along the way, Anaya's feelings changed.

She wasn't sure when it happened—maybe it was when Aarav stood up for her in middle school when a boy made fun of her, or maybe it was when he sneaked her extra fries during lunch. Or maybe it was the way he laughed, carefree and unbothered, as if the world couldn't touch him.

She had never planned to fall for him. But she did. And she fell hard.

The only place she could admit her feelings was in her diary. It was her safe space—where she poured out every stolen glance, every moment that made her heart race, and every wish she was too scared to say out loud.

Until the day she left it behind.

It happened so fast. One moment, she was gathering her books, rushing to the next class, and the next, her diary was gone.

A classmate found it. And instead of returning it, he opened it.

The words she had written in secret—her deepest emotions—were now in the hands of someone who had no right to them.

By lunchtime, the entire school knew.

"She likes Aarav?""She's been in love with him for years?""Did he know?"

Anaya could feel the stares, hear the hushed giggles, and see the curious glances. Everywhere she walked, people whispered.

Then came the moment she dreaded most.

Aarav found her after school, his expression unreadable. "Is it true?"

Anaya's heart pounded. She could deny it. Laugh it off. Say it was just a joke.

But she didn't want to lie.

"Yes," she whispered.

Aarav exhaled sharply, running a hand through his hair. He looked away for a moment before finally meeting her eyes. "Anaya… I don't feel that way about you."

The words stung more than she expected.

"I'm sorry," he added, his voice softer.

She forced a smile. "It's okay."

But as he walked away, she knew nothing would ever be the same again.